232 Members Online

The Newsstand The Qubbler January 2019 Discussion: Potions



<
>
Magical Archivist
Publications Mod
Magical Archivist - Publications Mod
Mixed Blood
Ravenclaw
Tell what's on your mind!
2nd year Witch
Status: Offline
Age: 28
Posts: 8,200

Salutations! As you may recall, the theme for December's Quibbler was potions! If you missed the December issue, never fear; you can check it out here.

PepperUp Potion, Hiccoughing Potion, Dreamless Sleep Potion, oh my! So many potions for so many things! How can one not love Potions?! This month, we'd like to hear your thoughts about these eclectic magical brews, so put on your Potion Master hats and dive right in!


Discussion questions to consider:
- What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?


RULES:
⁃ In order for you to be eligible to win, your post must be over 200 words long and relevant to the topic.
⁃ The best post will be chosen based on originality, points made, and how well it fits the topic of discussion.
⁃ All HEX terms apply; as such, all work must be your own.
⁃ Your discussion posts should be made in this thread by
11:59 PM HEX time on the 28th of January. Any posts submitted later than this will not be eligible for prizes.
⁃ Any questions can be posted in this thread or owled to Haley.


PRIZES:
Best Post: 1000 House Points + 2 raffle tickets
Randomized Winners:

1. 500 House Points
2. 500 House Points
3. 500 House Points
4. 250 House Points
5. 250 House Points


*Everyone who meets the minimum requirements, including the randomized winners, will earn 1 ticket towards The Newsstand's quarterly raffle.

[color=white]Edited by Morgan93
 

Pureblood
Slytherin
Hug your dog! Cracker- I want the item but keep the galleons- thanks!
4th year Wizard
Status: Offline
Age: 19
Posts: 35,455
What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
There were a couple like HEXian of the Month being Zen Squirrel. I know her and I truly think she is awesome without having to read the article. I was feeling terrible sad due to personal stuff happening at home and she took the time to chat with me about how I was doing. She would later send an occasional note to check up on me. The article is true but it can’t put into words what an exceptional person she is to me and all she encounters around her.

The next article had me laughing and saying “Yup, that’s Professor Slughorn, alright!” I felt bad for poor Katie who was thrilled to interview him. It’s funny how Professor Slughorn doesn’t realize he has insulted Katie. However, Katie does not let that stop her and pushes on with the interview. She was a trooper and did her best to not let him upset her. I was laughing at how Professor Slughorn couldn’t remember her name. It reminded me of Ron Weasley. Then Harry Potter happened to pass by and she was forgotten.

If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?
Why didn’t you shared your secrets when creating potions such as in your potion book that Harry Potter stole, I mean borrowed. What potion would you have used on your worst enemy and why?

[257]
 

Junior Staff
Gryff Subforum Mod
Junior Staff - Gryff Subforum Mod
Muggle Born
Gryffindor
Fly high Julie. <3 Goodbye is not forever, nor is it the end. It simply means I miss you until we meet again
6th year Witch
Status: Offline
Age: 29
Posts: 21,136
- What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
My favourite article was the Devil's Advocate article. I enjoy reading articles from alternative perspectives and the concept of illegal potion brewing definitely tickled my taste buds. I love the way that the Romeo and Juliet aspect was brought in, especially considering it's supposed to be a love play, but is actually a tragedy. I also love the editors note at the bottom and feel that it definitely adds to the quirkiness of the Quibbler, which is what makes it so unique.

⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
My favourite potion is probably a toss up between Veritaserum and Polyjuice Potion. I think that the Veritaserum potion would be particularly useful to get people to tell you the truth and ensure you have the full, accurate story, especially if it's for illegal potion brewing I also think that Polyjuice Potion would be a nice potion to brew too because it gives you the opportunity to be someone else and take a break from being you. An escape from reality essentially is what it could be.

⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
I reckon it would either be an invisibility potion so that they could get up to lots of different tricks, or it would be Amortentia. From a Muggle point of view, true love is hard to find, and even if it was used in the same way Merope used it on Tom Riddle, it would be possible for a Muggle to have someone infatuated with them.

⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
Modern Day, I think I would change into Professor McGonagall, just to see what life is like living as a determined, hard working, fair, person who has achieved a lot in their life. In days gone by, I'd love to have transformed into Snape to see just how many students actually liked him and how he interacted with people outside of work.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?
If you could be remembered for any one Potion, which potion would it be and why. I think a question like this would really let me understand the real Professor Snape and see what secrets he could divulge unwittingly with a question like this.
 

Muggle Born
Ravenclaw
2nd year Witch
Status: Offline
Age: 25
Posts: 4,088


I think I like the healing potions the most. Pepper-up Potion for example would be great in winter! They all work so much quicker than muggle medicines, and would help so many people. I also like Felix Felicis, and I think it would be really useful when inventing new potions or spells as it would be almost impossible to go wrong. It could also be used during dangerous situations like facing Voldemort!


I think potions for making people look better would be most popular. People would use a lot of beautifying potions every day. Rich people would also use Felix Felicis constantly I think.


I'm not sure I'd like to transform into anyone really. I like being myself. If I had to I might change myself into a museum/art gallery curator or something so I could have access to all of the beautiful things in storage for a while


I guess I'd ask Snape if he created the improvements to potions through trial and error, or if he just had a 'feeling' or instinct for what was correct. This really interests me because we don't really see anyone creating any spells or potions during the series, so we don't know how it would be done.

[206]
 

Mixed Blood
Slytherin
Big Christmas Giveaway- In Hogmeade. Come join the fun.
1st year Witch
Status: Offline
Age: 57
Posts: 1,844
What is your favorite potion and why? 

My favorite potion is Polyjuice Potion. Because then I could turn into whom ever I wanted to turn into. And make the ones that treated me badly when I was young pay in a small way. Like hitting them with Snowballs or Spit balls

⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used? 

If Muggles could use potions I think one of them would be the Draft of Dreamless Sleep, or Felix Felicis. But every Muggle would choose there own Potion that they would try.

⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why? 

If I had to use Polyjuice Potion. I would transform into my Great Granddaughter only because she's still a baby. Just to give her mother, my Granddaughter grief. Like she did to us when she was younger.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?

Is there a Potion that you have made that could help cure diseases of all kinds? Not just Magical diseases by Muggle ones too.


Edited by Cassy_61
 

Mixed Blood
Slytherin
"All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us." -Gandalf the Grey
2nd year Wix
Status: Offline
Age: 18
Posts: 3,170
-What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
My favorite article was probably Weirdities of the Wizarding World. If there were ever a book on wizarding life hacks, this would sure to be in it. (That would be a fun book to read!) I wish I could shrink all of my stuff and put it in a suitcase! I'm traveling to and from college every few weeks, and this would make packing so much easier!

⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
Absolutely Felix Felices. I'd be fascinated by how it works, and I'd really want to run some experiments on it, put someone in a series of situations where success becomes less and less likely and see what happened. I wonder, if a person who's had some Felix Felices is playing rock-paper-scissors, is their rate of winning higher if they have to win a greater percentage of the rounds? As in, does the potion somehow understand the context and know just how lucky the person has to be? Also, how exactly does it influence the laws of probability?

⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
Probably the Beautification Potion. People are obsessed with looks. It would probably become a routine substitute for daily makeup, etc. Either it would become commonplace or there would be a stygma against people who used it, or both.

⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
Probably my 6th grade science teacher, who I hated. Everyone hated him, he was awful and thought he was the greatest thing since sliced bread. I would transform into him and make a complete fool of myself (well, himself). I would wreck his desk and say awful things to the administration, so that he would be fired. Depending on the timing, I might even trash his home. I'm usually a very calm person, but some people I absolutely detest.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?
If you had to start drinking one potion every day during class, which would you choose?
Alternatively, if you could spike the drinks of every single student tonight at dinner, which potion would you choose?
 

Muggle Born
Gryffindor
Hi
4th year Witch
Status: Offline
Age: 22
Posts: 8,794
- What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
I think It was absurd questions cause I never thought about the similarities between cooking and potions and I find that very interesting.

⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
I think Felix Felicis as I like the idea of a little help being lucky, I am usually very unlucky

⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
I am between veritaserum and beautification. Don't tell me that parents wouldn't be happy to use veritaserum to make their kids confess their mischiefs


⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?

Hermione Granger. I adore her and I would love to be her for some hours.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?

What do you need to become a master in potions?
 

Muggle Born
Ravenclaw
“Don’t worry. You’re just as sane as I am.”
2nd year Witch
Status: Online
Age: 50
Posts: 31,316
My favorite potion is Dr. Ubbly's Oblivious Unction. Because I really do believe that injuries of the mind are the hardest to fix and the hardest to detect. In fact, it is possible that the damage that was done to Ron by the brains, may have in some way affected his behavior in the last book. We do not know if those trace memories may have stayed with him and influenced him in some way.

As far as the Muggles go, I think they would all go for Felix Felicis. People tend to choose what is worse for them, and too many of them would be thinking it would solve all their problems, if they could just win the lottery or something. This is why the Statute for Secrecy is so important. They just do not understand.
Personally I would only use the Polyjuice in the most extreme case. I think it is too dangerous for people to be impersonating others.

A question I would ask Professor Snape? I would ask him if there is a potion to fix a person’s eyesight. My eyes are so bad and I would just like to have perfect vision, which I have not had since the second grade.

(WC – 205)
 

Mixed Blood
Slytherin
"All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us." -Gandalf the Grey
2nd year Wix
Status: Offline
Age: 18
Posts: 3,170
Quote: Kestrel Winter

A question I would ask Professor Snape? I would ask him if there is a potion to fix a person’s eyesight. My eyes are so bad and I would just like to have perfect vision, which I have not had since the second grade.



Oh, absolutely! I figure there has to be some magical remedy, but Harry never gets his eyes fixed, so maybe there isn't. Of course, Snape would never tell him if there was.
 

Muggle Born
Gryffindor
"It unscrews the other way."
4th year Witch
Status: Offline
Age: 26
Posts: 3,303
What is your favorite potion and why?
Pepperup potion I think is one of the most useful. It would be nice to have something that could kick a cold.

⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
Probably health related potions. Being able to feel better is always a top priority.

⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
I don't think I would be comfortable turning into someone else. Though if I did I suppose I would turn into someone who had clearance into some top secret areas, because..why not.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?
I'd probably ask him about health potions.
 

Mixed Blood
Gryffindor
Champions Train Losers Complain .👈
4th year Witch
Status: Offline
Age: 14
Posts: 1,297
- What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
Superstitions was my favorite article because It was really really fun reading them .I enjoyed it a lot and I laughed a lot while reading it.

⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
polyjuice potion is my favorite portion . Because then I would turn into whom ever I like .I would turn into different person's and then I would get to experience their life for at least 1 hour . IT would also be very useful to me in many ways .I could also turn into celebrity's and meet other celebrity's .

-If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
Beautification portion .Because now days the world is running behind beauty .Every one's want's to become beautiful and Not everybody can be beautiful [from outside] . so now day's people are doing plastic surgeries and taking injections and medicines because they think looks are a representation of themself .so I think they would use the beautification portion most commonly.

⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
If I had polyjuice portion I would transfer into one member from Bts [korean boy band ]because I really adore them and love them and I would love to meet them .so I would turn into someone from the band and then I would talk to the other member's . I would do this because they won't allow normal people to go and meet them .so I would turn into one member from the band and meet others.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?
How to make new and good portions ?Since there is no cure for AIDS and in the world many people die because of AIDS so I would ask him to help me to make a portion to cure and prevent AIDS.
 

Magical Archivist
Nine-tailed fox
Sensate

Fairy princess

Queen of hearts
Magical Archivist - Nine-tailed fox - Sensate - Fairy princess - Queen of hearts
Earp Heir
Hufflepuff
Come join the Avatar Raffle in LU!
2nd year Witch
Status: Online
Age: 24
Posts: 25,013
-What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
I enjoyed Inside the Quibbler for its drama and animagus mentions.

⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
Felix Felicis is my favourite potion. I love everything about it – its golden colour, its quirky, cheerful nature, and its optimistic use. It also helps that Felix is one of my favourite names.

⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
If we’re talking canon, then probably healing potions. It would be so handy to be able to cure common ailments just with a sip of potion. I can also see beautification potions being a strong contender – people already go to such great lengths for their looks, sometimes spending millions of dollars on them, that to be able to use a simple potion for glowing skin and radiant hair would be very tempting.

⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
It would depend on context. Have I just been ordered to change into someone for fun? Then I’d definitely change into someone beautiful and enjoy how people gazed at me. Am I on a secret mission? Then I’d choose someone nondescript but athletic who would hopefully be able to help me achieve my goals.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?
In all honesty, I’d rather punch Snape in the face than utter a single word to him, but okay, I’ll play along. I would ask him the best method he knows to extend the shelf life of potions, as it must be annoying to have them go bad. Of course, he’d probably just say something like “Read a book, you disappointing mudblood” or something, and then I’d be extra-justified in cursing him.


[308]
 

Mixed Blood
Gryffindor
I'm not new (just busy) but my HEX mentor Kim Snape and Newbie Knowledge helped me a lot when I was new.
3rd year Witch
Status: Offline
Age: 33
Posts: 948
- What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
I couldn't choose a favorite. I just love the Quibbler and all articles.

⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
Probably Antidote for Common potions. It was easy to brew on Pottermore.

⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
They'd love a cleaning potion that did everything itself. Just spray the potion on any dusty, dirty, disorganized stuff and it would magically be cleaned and looking great.

⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
I'd turn into the U.S. president for a year and show that you can care about the environment and the people while still preerving people's pensions that are tied up in stocks and other investments.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be? How can I create my own potions and market them?
 

Mixed Blood
Slytherin
3rd year Witch
Status: Offline
Age: 19
Posts: 1,937
- What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
Alright so this is a really difficult question as I really enjoyed the majority of them. I remember reading Dangerous Beasts and chuckling to myself various times (how dare you insult my favourite, precious, cute little elephants >( ), Luna's Logs was very lovely to read as I felt that the character of Luna was captured really good- almost as if it was Luna herself describing the events in the parade! Also the interview with Crookshanks..it caught my attention and, well, I just love the fact that we got to see a glimpse inside the mind of Crookshanks..I once again realised how Slytherin that cat is...
⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
I would most probably like the healing potions (I mean like Skele-Gro, can you believe how less painful and easier everything would be for the patients?) the most, as my real life profession is in medicine and helping people comes naturally to me (almost like an instinct of some sort). Also Draught of Peace- how many people could be relieved from their anxiety, I just love everything about this potion <3
⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
Polyjuice Potion and Felix Felicis most probably. Although it is quite sad that so many people are unhappy with themselves to the point where they would be willing to completely change themselves into someone else, if given the option to see how you would feel like being someone else, probably few of us would have the strength of mind to stay true to themselves and not give in to the temptation. Also imagine being given access to Felix Felicis? Both of these potions are dangerous enough to become addicted to.
⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
I wouldn't use it. I mean, I get what the post tries to imply, what kind of person do you want to be? And of course there are various people whom I regard as having better looks, being more skilled in certain areas or who are better people than me, but I believe that everything is possible if you set your mind to it and that I'd rather achieve my goals without disowning my true self
⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?
What type of potions do you think are still very lightly understood and need to be researched further? Or maybe even this one: do you have any tips on how to do research on potions/how to create them? Is it natural to you for did you too need to put a lot of work before creating them?

Overall 403 words (assuming we do not count the questions)
 

Muggle Born
Slytherin
It's your local nonbinary pal! (please be my friend)
1st year Wix
Status: Offline
Age: 23
Posts: 1,792
-What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
The "You Didn't Hear It From Us" section was amazing. It was really quite creepy. I wonder where all those whispers are coming from? 😮
⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
My favorite potion is Felix Felicis. It is by far the most useful of any potion in the series, and beyond that, it's one of the prettiest.
⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
There would probably be widespread use of Amortentia and other love potions. They hold an appeal for most people.
⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
If I had to use Polyjuice Potion, I would probably transform into my brother, so I could see what it felt like to look like me, but be more masculine. I don't know if that makes sense to anyone else XD
⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?
I would ask Professor Snape if he had ever used Felix Felicis. I would suspect he had, at least once in his life.
 

Mixed Blood
Gryffindor
ISO Animal Models - Kelpie, Matagot, Mooncalf!
4th year Witch
Status: Online
Age: 66
Posts: 21,071
- What was your favorite article from this issue and why?
I liked the interview with Professor Slughorn best because the article really nailed his personality! I felt bad for the interviewer, Katie, because he kept forgetting her name, which he was known for doing with students he felt were unworthy of his attention (i.e. Ron Weasley).

⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?
I think my favorite potion is the Dreamless Sleep potion, mainly because of how it helped Harry to get some rest after his ordeal.

⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?
Oh, I think they'd soon find the limits of Felix Felicis, as that would likely be the most (over)used potion among Muggles. I could also see them using Amortentia and, among the less honest and more criminal-minded, Polyjuice Potion.

⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?
That's a tough one...I don't know that I'd want to transform into anyone else! I've run through in my mind a host of names of people I could transform into, and I get creeped out thinking about every one of them.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?
I would ask the Professor why he appeared to do so little actual teaching in his classes - he seemed to just berate Harry and his friends, throw the recipe for a potion up on the board and tell the students to brew it. I don't recall reading about him offering helpful information about technique - about cutting versus crushing of sopophorous beans, for example, and demonstrating how crushing released the juices better - to help his students succeed. He merely went around and approved or disapproved of the students' work and, rather than offering constructive criticism, only demeaned the students who were struggling. So, yeah, I'd ask Professor Snape why he didn't actually try to teach his students anything...after which I'd probably be hit with detention for the remainder of the school year and into the next...

[Word count - 288]
 

Mixed Blood
Ravenclaw
RAA: Free contest in Hogsmeade
2nd year Student
Status: Online
Age: 59
Posts: 5,976
- What was your favorite article from this issue and why?

It was hard to choose a favorite because they were all good but I think the one I liked the best was Superstitions. I laughed at some of the strange superstitions that it mentioned. Who knew that having a black cat sleep in your cauldron was good luck? I always thought that black cats were bad luck but sleeping in your cauldron is certainly something they would do. I have a cat (not a black one) and she will sleep in anything.

⁃ What is your favorite potion and why?

There are several potions that I would like to try but I think my favorite one is Felix Felicis or liquid luck. It would not only be very useful if you were doing something dangerous like hunting a dark wizard but who wouldn’t want to drink some and then go buy a lottery ticket.

⁃ If Muggles were able to use potions, what do you think would be the most commonly used?

I could certainly see muggles drinking felix felicis before doing some gambling or buying a lottery ticket. I could also see the beautification potion being popular. People would use it instead of makeup.

⁃ If you had to use Polyjuice Potion, who would you transform into and why?

I think I might transform into Professor Umbridge just so I could do something to ruin her day or that she would find embarrassing. Maybe I would confess to all the terrible things she had done like setting the dementors on Harry.

⁃ If you could ask Professor Snape one question about Potions, what would it be?

I think I would ask him why he never updated the potions books. He was clearly very talented in potions and could have easily added some improvements to the potion books. He certainly added his own in the one Harry used in sixth year.
 

To post in this thread, login or enroll here!


17 Years of Magic


Subsidiaries
Copyright ©2001-2019 HEXRPG, LLC. All rights reserved.
Hogwarts Extreme is an independent fan website. Images, content, Harry Potter © Warner Brothers, J.K. Rowling, and/or their respective owners. User content on this website is credited to the individuals.